02-06-25 A Letter From Our Servant Leaders

02-06-25 A Letter From Our Servant Leaders

02-06-25 A Letter From Our Servant Leaders 1200 1200 SVDP USA

Very unsettling news that became public this week has sent a shockwave through the Catholic charitable community. As it impacts one the largest and most important Catholic international aid organizations, it demands reflection and a realization of how policy that might appear to address one issue can have devastating impact on innocents.

Catholic Relief Services, CRS, is bracing for massive cuts — as much as 50% this year — because of draconian reductions in U.S. foreign assistance ordered by the new administration.

CRS is the top recipient of funds for foreign aid to support people in need around the world, aid which the administration has targeted with a spending freeze. Layoffs have already begun, as CRS has been forced to begin shutting down programs, as close to half of the organization’s $1.5 billion budget has been slashed. The cuts would amount to one of the biggest blows ever to CRS, founded in 1943 by Catholic bishops in the United States to serve World War II survivors in Europe. CRS reaches more than 200 million people in 121 countries on five continents.

This is a tragic outcome for people around the world who rely on CRS and others who believe in the call of Christ to ‘love your neighbor’ for survival. It is important that we pray for our sisters and brothers at CRS who are doing God’s work as they go through this turmoil, that we pray for the innocents who will suffer because of these actions, and for an understanding by policymakers of the universal impact of their actions and a consideration of all impacted by those actions before they are taken.

This is not about politics. Politicians get elected and they have a right to enact the policies that they ran on and were elected on. No, this is about morality and doing what is right. This is about not cutting off your head because you have a cold. This is about not blowing up your house because your sink leaks. This is about thinking about the impact of your actions before you take them.

There is no excuse for making the poor, the hungry, the homeless, and the sick suffer while you ‘study’ the massive expenditures of the federal government. If there is waste, identify where, and cut it. You’ll be applauded. Don’t shut down vital lifesaving aid to millions while you look — people die that way. Look first, act second.

This is about the fact that we, as Christians, believe that caring for the poor, the homeless, the sick, and the elderly is not just a moral duty. It’s a divine mandate from God and Jesus. This obligation is deeply rooted in the teachings of the Bible and the example set by Jesus Christ during His earthly ministry.

The Bible is replete with verses that emphasize the importance of helping those in need. In the Old Testament, God commands His people to care for the less fortunate. For instance, in Deuteronomy 15:11, it is written, “For there will never cease to be poor in the land. Therefore, I command you, ‘You shall open wide your hand to your brother, to the needy and to the poor, in your land.'” This verse highlights the perpetual presence of poverty and the continuous need for generosity and compassion.

The teachings of Jesus in the New Testament further reinforce this obligation. Jesus’ ministry was marked by His compassion for the marginalized and the suffering. In Matthew 25:35-40, Jesus speaks about the final judgment and identifies Himself with the needy. We know that this passage underscores the idea that serving the needy is equivalent to serving Christ Himself.

Moreover, the parable of the Good Samaritan (Luke 10:25-37) illustrates the call to love and care for others, regardless of their background or circumstances. The Samaritan’s actions demonstrate that true neighborly love transcends social and ethnic boundaries and is characterized by mercy and compassion.

The early Christian community also exemplified this mandate. In Acts 2:44-45, it is recorded that “all who believed were together and had all things in common. And they were selling their possessions and belongings and distributing the proceeds to all, as any had need.” This communal sharing and support for the needy were foundational to the early Church’s identity and mission.

So too do Governments have a fundamental obligation to support those in need during policy making. This responsibility is rooted in the principles of life, liberty, justice, and the common good. Effective governance requires that policies are designed to uplift the most vulnerable members of society, ensuring that everyone has access to basic necessities and opportunities for a better life.

Historically, U.S. governmental entities (both Republican and Democratic) have reached out to Catholic organizations in order to deliver social services more effectively and efficiently. America has a profound moral obligation to support those in need, both domestically and globally. This responsibility stems from the nation’s values of justice, compassion, and leadership. As a global leader, the United States has the capacity and resources to make a significant impact on alleviating suffering worldwide.

Moreover, America’s history of humanitarian aid reflects its commitment to global welfare. The Marshall Plan, for instance, helped rebuild Europe after World War II, demonstrating the nation’s dedication to fostering stability and prosperity beyond its borders. By supporting those in need globally, America not only fulfills its moral obligations but also promotes peace, stability, and goodwill. This approach fosters international cooperation and strengthens global partnerships, ultimately contributing to a more just and peaceful world.

In summary, Christians are called to care for the poor, the homeless, the sick, and the elderly as a reflection of God’s love and compassion. This mandate is not merely a suggestion, but a fundamental aspect of Christian discipleship, rooted in the teachings of the Bible and the example of Jesus Christ. By serving those in need, Christians fulfill their divine obligation and embody the love of Christ in the world.

Peace and God’s blessings,
John

John Berry
SVdP National President

82 Comments
  • Sorry but it does seem you are making this about politics and your rant seems to align with that of the USCCB which is meddling into leftist politics instead of staying completely out of politics. The U.S. government is full of fraud, waste and abuse just as the the distribution of goods by SVDP. Yes, I have witnessed it from the USG and SVDP. There is a point when you must put a stop and fix what is broken. You cannot empty a tub while you leave the faucet open and that is the situation with USAID as well as other agencies. With all due respect I suggest you refrain from commenting and trying to play a blame game when you start meddling into politics and do not have all the facts. All you will do is alienate people like myself that volunteer or donate at SVDP.

    Blessings

    • Margaret Kolman-Mandle February 6, 2025 at 6:38 pm

      This is not politics. This is basic Christianity. The wholesale closing of USA ID hurts millions of men, women, and children all for Trump‘s political purposes. Your lack of empathy for those affected is beyond belief.

      • It’s not “Tump’s political purposes”…..the US people elected him to do exactly what he is doing……to stop the corruption that has taken over our country for years! Your apathy toward the massive abuses that have infested all levels of our government is shocking! God is about charity, but the is also about order and truth! Why don’t we all try to remember that first, and trust that God alone is in control, and stop trying to use this situation to demonize others for personal gain! God will see us ALL through the truth being exposed, no matter who or where we are!
        God bless!!

      • 100%. this is basic principled Christianity. For those needing further understanding, I recommend Father Mike Schmitz podcast the Catechism in a year. buy catechism of the church second edition to accompany the podcast. The text intro instructs us to learn fully the Catechism be taken as a whole.

    • Very well said. I agree!

    • Exactly David. I have always hoped that SVDP was not aligned with the liberal quasi Catholics.. This certainly makes us wonder about whether SVDP is committed to our Faith. We have so much bad going on in our Church hierarchy here in our Country and at the Vatican. Let’s steer clear of all that a tell the truth at SVDP.

    • I believe John’s words reflect Catholic Social teaching. WE are called to challenge policies that go against our faith values His paragraph “There is no excuse for making the poor, the hungry, the homeless, and the sick suffer while you ‘study’ the massive expenditures of the federal government. If there is waste, identify where, and cut it. You’ll be applauded. Don’t shut down vital lifesaving aid to millions while you look — people die that way. Look first, act second.” does that.
      thank you John..

      • Completely agree. This should never be about partisan politics the what this administration is doing is akin to taking a chainsaw to a hangnail. It is the opposite of Christianity and is so very wrong.

      • Your comments are very relevant to what is occurring in the government today! We have a responsibility as Catholics to call out and condemn abusive behavior when we see it. If we don’t then we are also guilty of abuse. Acting indiscriminately is abusive behavior.

      • Well put. This Elon Musk approach is one I have seen with administrators trying to “sweep with a new broom” by causing the problem and then running in with the “solution.” This approach never improved anything that I could identify as a public school teacher. I doubt very much it will work in the government.

    • Bonnie Fiorentino February 7, 2025 at 7:20 am

      Unfortunately politics affect everything. Some not all get involved with Charitable organizations for the wrong reasons. . I do think that all charitable organizations need to get back to basics and cut the fat at the top. However . I am President of a small SVDP conference in Cape May County NJ. We don’t waste $1.
      All of our funds collected go to serving the friends in need. We pay a only a small amount for solidarity dues to belong to the National sVDP. Our volunteer members take a collection each month at our meetings to cover thank you cards and stamps to send to our benefactors. I urge you to get involved with your local SVDP and please continue to support them.

    • Melanie Seibert, District of Evansville February 8, 2025 at 7:13 am

      But we don’t “throw the baby out with the bathwater,” to continue in your metaphor.

    • Sorry David, I disagree with you. John’s thoughts are based on Jesus and Scripture. If you’ve ever entered the lives of the needy and suffered along with them you realize what they are up against. Getting rid of waste is necessary. Sometimes too, is erring on the side of mercy. If you’ve ever been really hungry with no food around, or out of work with a child to feed, clothe, house, and love you’d get what I’m saying. Do we really need to shut everything down to find waste? I don’t think so. Do we need to fire thousands and thousands of government employees to find waste and save money? I don’t think so. People in SVDP and CRS carry the burdens of the people whom they try to serve. This is much different from just looking at a spreadsheet and nixing the whole spreadsheet. It’s a question of understanding and of compassion.

      Bob Wondolowski

    • Currently administrations are political by nature and have no intention of fixing anything. Job security is their only concern!

    • If there is fraud, waste and corruption then our job as stewards is to seek it out and fix it wherever we find it. This should be a focused surgical correction without killing the patient.

      We should not loose sight of the underlying issue…our relationship with the truth. We teach our children to tell the truth…all ways. Sadly, truth is now determined by political leanings. Trump, his believers and media supporters shout from the roof tops that he did not loose the 2020 Presidential Election when all evidence (60 court cases attorney General Barr etc.) confirms the free and fair election of Biden.

      Follow the truth.

  • Let’s see how it all washes out. No cuts have been finalized as of now, per an article in the Baltimore Banner.

    • Margaret Kolman-Mandle February 6, 2025 at 6:32 pm

      I don’t know where you’re getting your information but all USAID workers have been told to come back to the United States. Some were told to come back within four days, even if they had families and homes and other countries. Many relief services are laying off people because they don’t have money to pay their salaries

  • I am a faithful Catholic and am ashamed to point out the corruption of Catholic Relief Services and many other organizations under USCCB, most notably Catholic Campaign for Human Development. Many with8n and without the Catholic Church have sadly reported on this.. A fantastic source is The Lepanto Institute and here is just one report regarding CRS.
    https://www.lepantoin.org/wp/report-catholic-relief-services-government-funding-and-contraception/
    On their website you can check out many other charities as to whether they deserve our support.
    I can only pray that the light now being shined on the USCCB would cause the laity to take stock of what’s been happening in our Church and that the bishops would repent.

    • I am a Vincentian and am very upset by the funding shutoff for USAID and the resultant stoppage of many Catholic Relief Services programs. The abrupt stoppage is terrible. The baby is being thrown out with the bath water.

      Reports today say that tons of soybeans are now left to rot in trucks that were en route to starving people. American farmers are likely to suffer because a lot of their crops went to USAID.

      Sited Lepanto Institute reports focus on exposing CRS programs that include contraception and other sexually related education programs that don’t align with official Catholic doctrine. Such programs are connected to AIDS and 10-year-old girls’ pregnancy prevention among other serious health issues. I, for one, believe the Church should not ban birth control any more than it should ban other “artificial” medical interventions like heart bypass surgeries or antibiotics. So if AIDS and child pregnancies are to be prevented, what does the Lepanto Institute suggest?

      CRS provides so many services that follow the teachings of Christ. He was quite liberal in contrast to the high priests, and scribes who insisted on following the letter of the Jewish law of the time.

    • Lepanto Institute is NOT a reputable source of information. He’s a one-man-band who’s been echoed by other site like catholic life site and catholic vote, but it’s bogus information. CRS has repeatedly invited him to to see their books and he’s come, but still spins his false narrative and lies which divides the Catholic Church. Please look at other sources.

  • Right on!

      • An organization whose web site is not even secure.

        • The letter from the SVDP President attacking the valid actions taken on behalf of the new administration to root out corrupt spending was disappointing and political. The truth about the extent of the corruption is truly unfathomable. It’s is extremely frustrating to know that The USCCB and apparently our Society leaders favor the continuation of these atrocities.

          • Lepanto Institute is NOT a reputable source of information. He’s a one-man-band who’s been echoed by other site like catholic life site and catholic vote, but it’s bogus information. CRS has repeatedly invited him to to see their books and he’s come, but still spins his false narrative and lies which divides the Catholic Church. Please look at other sources.

          • I think Christ would use the word atrocity to apply to dehumanizing people, demonizing our neighbors and putting profit ahead of love and service. Human beings will starve while “corruption” is “studied.”

  • I agree with everything you said 100%. Every Catholic who voted for Mr. Trump should pray fully consider how their actions have resulted in hurting millions of people. We were given plenty of warning in Project 2025 that foreign aid was slated to be eliminated. Why didn’t people believe it?

    • Margaret Kolman-Mandle February 6, 2025 at 6:35 pm

      Totally agree. People are being hurt, but he’s unwarranted cuts. If there were problems addressed them. i

  • Thank you for this. I agree 100%. Can you post this letter and further letters, speeches etc.. on the SSVDP Facebook page? We can share these messages on our Conference page.
    Thanks!

  • Thank you, John, for putting our principles into a well thought out essay. It will be shared with many.
    God bless you for being the type of leader we need for our country.

  • John, Thank you for a powerful message. May it be widely seen and shared and may it change hearts and minds for decision-makers. Thank you for using your voice to advocate for better policies! Julie

  • Sandra,

    You really need to stop watching CNN and relying on their every word. Trump had nothing to do with Project 2025 with has been noted on several occasions and no matter how much the leftist media repeats it, it does not make it true. Furthermore, every Catholic that did not vote for Pres. Trump needs to realize all the great things that have been done to save millions of lives and all within 3 weeks. Harris was all for targeting Catholics with the FBI, abortion, war, etc., all things that Pres. Trump is putting and end to. But you need to look beyond the liberal media to know these things.

  • Thank you for addressing this and providing specifics of the impact. I think we all support eliminating any abuse or fraud, but I agree with your comments about first having a plan. The most vulnerable humans are being impacted and you clearly explained our role as Christians!

  • John,
    I disagree with you on many of your points. I agree with the others who have rightly pointed out that your screed is, indeed, political. As Americans we have every right to demand that our tax dollars are spent prudently and wisely. These aren’t private, charitable donations made to USAID which donors can cut off if they are misspent. Each day more examples of misuse come to light, many for purposes that are contrary to Catholic teaching.
    CRS and The Campaign for Human Development are not entirely faithful to the Gospel message, as others have pointed out.
    It is my understanding that The Rule specifies that the Society is not to be political. Please reflect a bit more before you opine and seemingly make it appear to be.

  • The list of all the DEI spending by USAID that I have seen is disgusting. The list of programs regarding DEI in other countries did nothing to relieve the suffering of the poor in other nations. Our “leaders” within USAID oversaw this unwarranted spending. If you leave those people in place, then this kind of nonsense continues. So in my mind, the only way to correct this situation is to tear the structure down and rebuild it with different people at the helm. USAID looks like a lot of government institutions where the bureaucracy costs more than what is provided in the aid handed out.

  • I would start with the compensation of the top three in CRS, which totals well over $1 Million. Really? That, to me, is problematic. Then I would ask, across its programs, where does CRS really align with Gospel values. My guess is that many are overlays with many secular aid programs that do not align. I will agree with the concerns of “draconian” cuts. Christ made draconian requests of disciples… “Sell what thou hast and come follow Me”. He did not start with a list of possessions from which to choose.. and many turned away. Surely those whose work is suspended are in extremis today and there may have been a kinder way to affect USAID. But, I do not believe that CRS stands alone as an organization that deserves any more painful hand’wringing than other affected NGOs. “Charity” like any other work rattling its hat for funds is subject to corruption and misuse of donor generosity and expectations.. Maybe this whirlwind circumstance is an opportunity for a reset in how taxpayer and donor largesse is better served.

  • Excellent letter. Thank you, Mr. Berry.

  • Jim Koerber, 2-5-25
    Below is an excellent Facebook post by Rick Steves.
    In my career, I worked with USAID personnel in various countries, all trying to make a better life for so many. My St. Vincent de Paul wrist band states: “Love Your Neighbor”. This is not only necessary in our country but in all countries around the world. We assist those in need. That’s what makes us a better country and better Christians!
    Rick Steves, 2-3-25, Dump Thy Neighbor?
    As our new president and his favorite broligarch move to dismantle US foreign aid in the name of making America “great again,” consider this:
    There are 8 billion people on this planet. About half of them live on less than $7 a day. Around 10% are in what the UN calls “extreme poverty” — trying to live on less than $2 a day. And 4% of the world’s population are Americans who live on an average of about $220 per day.
    Before January 21, when Trump froze virtually all foreign aid, the US allocated slightly less than 1% of its wealth to help the world’s poorest people. And for more than 60 years, that work has been done by the US Agency for International Development (USAID), whose goal is both self-serving and compassionate: to “further America’s interests while improving lives in the developing world.”
    This weekend, Trump declared USAID is run by “liberals and lunatics” — and Elon Musk tweeted it was “time for it to die” as his crew took over the agency’s offices and demanded access to classified material. And today, with Musk crowing, “We spent the weekend feeding USAID into the woodchipper,” we are learning that Marco Rubio is now in control of the agency.
    Trump was elected by the most conservative Christians in the USA. But all Christians, whether liberal or conservative, follow the teachings of Jesus Christ — and if you distill Jesus’s message into three words, it’s “love thy neighbor.” As a traveler, I’ve come to understand that if there is a God, then all people are children of their heavenly creator. Therefore, we are all brothers and sisters. And logically, proximity (what country you happen to live in) has nothing to do with “love thy neighbor.”
    But let’s just say the typical MAGA American Christian is more of a nationalist than a Christian (a.k.a. a “Christian Nationalist,”) and they care more about being rich and safe than actually loving thy neighbor. The president those Christian Nationalists helped elect, whose slogan is “Make America Great Again,” is in the process of dismantling humanitarian aid in the interest of saving tax dollars. But ironically, pulling out of this work will actually make America less safe and less great. Forgetting about any ethical or Christian-compassion dimension of foreign aid, ending these programs will make the Global South both more desperate and less stable — leaving a huge vacuum for China (which seems to understand the concept of “soft power” much better than MAGA Americans) to fill in these weakened countries. And to top it off, millions of people will no longer be providing a market for us to trade with — and will instead become refugees.
    As a traveler who has spent about three months a year overseas for 40 years, who has researched and produced a one-hour TV special called “Hunger and Hope: Lessons from Ethiopia and Guatemala” (www.ricksteves.com/hunger), and whose primary teaching and philanthropic goals have been to fight poverty at home and abroad, I’ve learned something very fundamental: Even if you’re only motivated by greed, if you know what’s good for you and your loved ones, you don’t want to be filthy rich in a desperately poor world. It’s just not a pretty picture.
    And if you really want to make America great, the best possible use of US tax dollars is to continue to dedicate less than 1% of the total federal budget to fighting global poverty — not in the name of Jesus, but in the name of a more stable and prosperous world where the USA is a strong leader. (And talk about a twofer…you get to love thy neighbor as well!)
    Concerned? Raise your voice!

    • Serving as a conduit for taxpayer money is not charity, even less when used for so many dubious purposes.

    • What’s missing here is the reality of the consequences of sin. The evidence for CRS, CCHD, THE USCCB and many other leaders in the Church is one sin and corruption. While there may be good people and good deeds within these organizations, the consequences of immoral promotion of sin and a search for revenue from the government to pad the pockets of these organizations while denying basic truths of the faith which should be guiding their actions, is that they must be held accountable. If someone works for or is served by a corrupt organization, they are affected by this accountability. The bishops and many others either don’t care about the sins or don’t believe what the Church teaches in its totality. Let’s do better at SVDP.

    • Tom and Kathy Williams February 7, 2025 at 3:32 pm

      Thanks, Jim. Great letter.

    • Can you think of ANY reason for humanitarian aid to be CLASSIFIED? When one is critical of actions that illuminate the clandestine nature of an organization that was founded on alleviating suffering, you have to wonder what the real motivation is. As Vincentians, we are in a ministry that should be apolitical, but the comments I have read so far are far from that. We serve the poor, let Caesar be given his due and let us, as Vincentians, give to God by giving our all to the poor. Bob Coburn, Holy Child, Tijeras, NM

    • Margaret Kolman-Mandle February 9, 2025 at 12:52 pm

      Thank you so much for this post Jim. The comments following the posted letter are very distressing to me. USA ID performs such critical work in both the US and particularly Overseas. The lies and incorrect information being spread are beyond distressing. Cutting off all USA ID funds will have horrible consequences for millions of people. It is unbelievable to me that those involved with SVDP are so uncaring, uninformed, and nasty

  • A couple of things we all must keep in mind. Our federal government has the following responsibilities: Lawmaking, Social Security, Taxation, Commerce, National defense,
    Foreign affairs, Medicare, Monetary policy, Naturalization, Federal courts. We have gone too far with what our federal government takes on and it’s time to go back to basics. The responsibilities of taking care of our brothers and sisters in Christ, belongs to each of us, individually we need to show compassion, have an open heart.
    Also the math does not add up $1.5 billion and serving 200 million is only $7.50 per individual.
    Our focus must change! All too often we want to contribute to brick and mortar, when we should be contributing to help people!
    Blessing to all,
    Larry

  • Thank you John for highlighting CRS. It’s been ten years or so since I stopped donating to CRS and now support Cross International. CRS had a high overhead rate compared to other charitable organizations. Additionally, CRS appears to support abortion and other contraceptives that are opposed to Catholic teaching. Having heard a litany of abuses by USAID and the need to shut down for further examination, it might be good for CRS to examine itself and return to its original mission.

    • Margaret Kolman-Mandle February 7, 2025 at 7:05 am

      I don’t know where you’re getting your information, but it is not not accurate.

      • See the link above with all the receipts. And there are countless others.
        Just today I received this from Father Shenan Boquet, the president of Human Life International which has been fighting for life across the globe for decades and runs into USAID and the other NGO’s affiliated with the Catholic Church.
        Excerpt from his email:

        Good news! USAID is defunded. Here’s what’s next:

        Hi Mr. Cohoat,

        You’ve probably heard by now that President Trump is defunding USAID.

        This is a HUGE win for life and family around the world!

        For decades, your missionaries have been fighting an uphill battle against taxpayer-funded, anti-life organizations.

        You might have seen some of the crazy USAID projects:
        $2 million for LGBT activism in Guatemala
        $50 million to send condoms to Gaza
        $5.5 million to peddle LGBTQ ideology in Uganda
        $47,000 to put on a transgender opera in Colombia
        …the list goes on and on.

        By defunding USAID, President Trump turned off one spigot of money for anti-life groups. I’m excited to see how this helps your mission globally.

        But here’s the thing: we can’t sit back and relax. There’s only one way to stop the anti-child agenda once and for all. You’re needed to change hearts and minds on a grassroots level.

        Defunding USAID is a great start. It removes some of the top-down pressure. But organizations like the Gates Foundation will continue funding anti-life projects, no matter what. And there are so many communities hurting from years of these attacks.

        Right now, girls are suffering from the physical effects of hormonal birth control. Young kids are confused by gender ideology. And so many families are broken because of the terrible sex-education your tax dollars funded.

        It makes me angry. How dare the government use my money this way! But as an American, I can’t just walk away.

        That’s why I’m reaching out to you today. Because of your generosity, missionaries have been fighting this agenda for years. They know exactly how to help families right now. But they can’t change anything without your help.

        This is the critical moment. Right now, anti-life groups are off balance, trying to regroup. Meanwhile, your missionaries are right there, ready to go. They’re just waiting for you.

        • Thank you for knowing your facts. The US Government should be involved with Charity. Look at how they step in and force evil non Catholic programs onto us. We do not need USAID, or any monies from any government.

      • Consider me from Georgia and show me.

  • This article and many of the replies are very disappointing to me for 2 reasons. (1) There are many moral issues to be considered when voting. Among them are the sanctity of life and the need to stop enabling human trafficking at our border. If you are unaware of these issues and think one party has the moral high ground, you need better news source(s). 58 percent of Catholics voted for this administration. If you think they don’t know what they are doing, you need to learn more about some issues. A condescending attitude is not consistent with Vincentian virtues. Condescension on top of ignorance is particularly troubling. (2) Although the author asserts “this is not about politics”, it clearly is. Look up the definition of politics and compare to your assertions about draconian acts by the administration. Given that many Vincentians voted for this administration for valid reasons, the article alienates a wide swath of Vincentians and makes them reflect on whether they should continue or take their desire to help elsewhere. I fail to see how that helps the poor. Our leadership should bring us together by focusing on our mission rather than dividing us based on an opinions about allocation of public funds in the face of a $36 trillion deficit.

  • Whatever comes of this, we still have to live with the current administration for the coming 4 years. Let’s not fall to division, but prepare and do our best with what we have to continue to serve our neighbors in need. We must trust in the Lord’s plan, as we continue His work together

  • This video by Catholic Charities was very damaging and will effect the support we receive from our donors. I would like to believe that government support for the Catholic Church will be reinstated at some point. Right now it is a casualty of all the wasteful spending that has been uncovered. In the meantime we have to continue with our mission the best we can!

    https://nypost.com/2025/01/27/us-news/catholic-charities-draws-fire-over-video-coaching-illegal-migrants-on-how-to-duck-ice/

  • Catholic Charities should be funded only by Catholics. and other Christian organizations. the government should not be involved. . if Catholics accept government funds it automatically becomes political.

  • Many people think the Inited States is one great big money tree where anyone in the world can come a pick their fill. With the 36 trillion in debt it’s roots are being eaten away. Nearly every dollar spent is borrowed. That is not a responsible way to run a country. There were no articles of complaint when our government was spending money on abortion and sexual mutilation of children, drug trafficking or human slavery. Now you are suddenly taking the moral high ground when fraud and abuse is being addressed. When much of the money distributed is going into someone’s pocket, the poor of the world are not being helped. It’s time someone figures out how to help the poor without enriching those in charge of helping the poor. Jesus never said give your money to Caesar so he can pass some of it along, he said help the least of my brothers.

    • Well said! Decisions on the distribution of PUBLIC funds (Caesar, in your analogy) are, BY DEFINITION, politics. If the Society is not “political”, it has no role in those decisions.

  • Why is the Catholic Church continually relying on government support to aid those in need? Government support always comes with strings attached. My husband and I stopped giving to Catholic Relief Services years ago, when we found out they were supporting contraception programs in Central America–probably to comply with directives from the U.S. government. There are so many smaller charities that do so much REAL good overseas…do a little research and find one or two or three and start supporting them. And quit relying on the U. S. government to do all the good YOU ARE supposed to be doing, because while our government does SOME good, they also do a whole lot that is sinful.

  • If you work for or deal with CRS, you will find out that they stopped being a truly “CATHOLIC” organization a long time ago and act more like a US Goverment agency.

  • Thank you, John, for your well-written article. I’m disheartened when I think about the negative effects of this action on so many people who live in extreme poverty. There is nothing political about the mandate to love our neighbors and to share our resources to help others.

  • Thank you for your leadership in defense of our allies Catholic Charities and Catholic Relief Services. Cardinal Cupich also said it well: https://www.chicagocatholic.com/cardinal-blase-j.-cupich/-/article/2025/02/05/setting-the-record-straight

  • Rochelle Woodland February 7, 2025 at 3:35 pm

    John,
    I am grateful to you for stepping out on Faith to remind us of our mission. First we’re a network of friends. Friends can disagree but continue to express thoughts and passions. I know this, Jesus came to save me, and you, and you. Fruit comes through actions of helping those in need and WE RECEIVE THE BLESSING. It’s a honor to be allowed to love God! Sometimes we are the only Christ neighbors in need will see. I wonder would some of our neighbors in need would feel reading the replies.

  • Obviously a great deal of prayer is still needed on this topic. There are still more in need in my area than our conference can handle. I will continue to help those in need as I can looking for the face of Christ in each of them while this matter is discussed. Open conversation with Jesus will lead us to where we need to be. We can each make a difference!

  • At a time when we are challenged to recruit new members for our conferences and working hard to ensure our treasuries have funds available to help our neighbors, taking such a polarizing view of what is happening in Washington D.C. is counterproductive. Many other posts have done a good job of explaining why the rush to judge this as a cruel and unhuman act is overblown, so I don’t care to add further to those arguments. Simply put, our country is on an unsustainable path towards bankruptcy at estimates of $36T in debt. This doesn’t even account for unfunded obligations. The Unites States federal government wouldn’t be in a position to contribute to worthy charitable programs much if the looming economic crisis were to materialize. The proverbial saying about a “few bad apples” is relevant here. When egregiously wasteful programs are lavishly funded, it casts doubt on other, potentially legitimate, outlays. The mission of DOGE isn’t to sort out validity of one program over another but rather to identify waste. After the rightful departments, OMB, etc. have reviewed what has been identified, there will be a chance for funding to resume with proper oversight. I’m a Vincentian and believe wholeheartedly on the Rule we were founded upon, but I also work for a private-sector company. In that capacity, my department needs to justify budget every year. Our executive management is always looking for cost-cutting measures to trim things that aren’t working as effectively as they should be. Government should be no different! Some would argue that agencies should have zeroed out budgeting, where every year they need to apply for their funding anew. This can be disruptive to ongoing programs and add delays like were called out in this article. I don’t subscribe to this. There needs to be a happy medium. Shaming those that have posted contrary opinions in this blog to that espoused by John Barry is only going to serve to divide us further. I don’t believe that my position is any less Christian for wanting to see long-overdue reform in my government than those who would like to see funding restored immediately.

  • Lord Jesus,
    Deepen our Vincentian spirit of friendship. Make us responsive to the Christian calling to seek and find the forgotten, the suffering or the deprived so that we may bring them you love…. Perfect in us your love. May we not forget !
    Gene Smith, Past President

  • The United States Government is not a charity and should be funding any charities, including SVdP. This is not right and trying to justify it by quoting bible verse makes us look a non denominational church broadcast asking for those crisp 20 dollar bills. I am going to continue to pray that we do not receive funds from the United States or any Government. We are better than this!

  • Everyone;

    I rarely, if ever, post here after one of my Servant Leader columns. But there is a lot of misinformation and misunderstanding being posted, so I am going to attempt to provide a few facts and clarifications and step away.
    First, this is not about politics. If you think it is, that’s your opinion. Don’t dare impugn my motives.
    Second, a few of you seem to be confusing CRS with another organization. Get your facts right. CRS was never involved in a scandal about contraception.
    Third, the CRS Board has a majority of Cardinals, Bishops, and Priests; including the former SVdP National Spiritual Advisor Bishop Hying.
    Fourth, this is about cut to CRS Programs, not USAID. Many people (myself included) believe USAID needs reform. That doesn’t mean CRS should suffer.
    Finally, for those who don’t understand the difference between CRS and USAID – here’s some information to help.
    Both USAID (United States Agency for International Development) and CRS (Catholic Relief Services) are major players in global humanitarian aid and development, but they differ in their funding sources, operational structures, and service priorities. Here’s a comparison:

    1. Funding and Organizational Structure
    • USAID: A U.S. government agency primarily funded by taxpayer dollars. It distributes grants and contracts to NGOs (including CRS), private firms, and foreign governments.
    • CRS: A nonprofit organization affiliated with the Catholic Church, receiving funding from USAID, private donations, and other sources like the Catholic community and international partners.

    2. Scope of Services
    • USAID: Primarily focuses on long-term international development goals and foreign policy interests of the U.S. It funds large-scale projects in health, education, governance, economic growth, and humanitarian aid.
    • CRS: Implements humanitarian and development programs with a focus on Catholic social teachings, prioritizing poverty alleviation, disaster relief, and faith-based development initiatives.

    3. Geographic Reach
    • USAID: Operates in over 100 countries with an emphasis on U.S. strategic interests, often partnering with governments and large international organizations.
    • CRS: Works in about 100 countries but often focuses on vulnerable, marginalized communities, regardless of political interests.

    4. Key Areas of Assistance

    Disaster Relief
    USAID; Funds emergency response efforts and works through partners like the UN and NGOs.
    CRS; Directly provides aid through its global network of Catholic organizations.

    Health
    USAID; Invests heavily in global health initiatives (HIV/AIDS, maternal health, malaria, vaccines).
    CRS; Focuses on community health programs, nutrition, and HIV/AIDS prevention, often through faith-based healthcare networks.

    Education
    USAID; Supports large-scale education reform and literacy programs in developing nations.
    CRS; Works on grassroots educational initiatives, including Catholic schools and community training.

    Food Security
    USAID; Runs Feed the Future and similar large-scale programs.
    CRS; Implements food distribution and agricultural support in crisis regions.

    Economic Development
    USAID; Promotes trade, infrastructure, and policy reforms for economic stability.
    CRS; Focuses on microfinance, small-scale agriculture, and local entrepreneurship.

    5. Faith-Based vs. Secular Approach
    • USAID: A secular government agency, working with a mix of religious and non-religious organizations.
    • CRS: Operates under Catholic principles but serves people of all faiths and backgrounds.

    Key Contrast
    • USAID is a government donor and policymaker, funding large-scale global programs.
    •. CRS is an implementing organization, delivering aid and programs directly, often with a faith-based approach.

    Since CRS relies heavily on USAID grants, funding cuts reduce its ability to deliver healthcare, food aid, and emergency relief—especially in crisis regions where it is one of the few reliable service providers.

    Peace and God bless,
    John

    • Mr. Berry,
      I find your defense of CRS to be short on facts and high in narrative creation.
      I hope you have taken the opportunity to peruse the complete report from The Lepanto Institute which I referenced in my first comment. There are many examples and documentation of the problems with CRS including their support of abortion, contraception and other sins.
      You will also note that much of the criticism of the corruption is aimed at the USCCB, which has lost all credibility for their actions supporting all kinds of evil and their unwillingness to call out the disastrous policies of many politicians, most notably Joe Biden. The blood money the bishops have taken for CRS, CCHD, Catholic Charities , etc. can all be lumped in one cesspool of misdeeds and corruption.
      I will share here another even more comprehensive report on CRS which goes back many years with specifics on dozens of scandals.
      https://www.lepantoin.org/wp/crs/

      I can’t tell you how disappointed many of are to realize how SVDP appears to be addressing the numerous evident problems.
      In giving a charitable benefit of the doubt to you, I hoped it was out of naïveté or ignorance of the issues. If, after a serious review of the voluminous information and much available elsewhere, you are still wedded to your narrative, I’d urge consideration, with others at SVDP, whether this type of leadership is proper for a faithful Catholic organization.
      This soul searching and reflection is a beautiful fruit of the light being shined on the corruption and sinfulness of bishops and other leaders in our Church.
      Blessings,
      John Cohoat

  • John,

    Your latest post does clarify some of the confusion we saw about the relationships between USAID, CRS, etc. Thank you for that.
    That said, one universal truth about communication is “if lots of people see something that wasn’t intended, the communication wasn’t done well”. Even if you intended to stay away from politics, your message emboldened some to shame others for how they voted and directly alienated others. Hopefully there is a lesson.

    • Jim,
      Point taken. But it is a sad reality of today’s world is that even the simplest and most benign statement on any topic seems to create a divide amongst people. We have become a nation and a world where Steven Covey’s 5th habit ‘Seek first to understand, and then to be understood.’ has been replaced by ‘Seek first to speak loudest and longest; ignore the facts, and attack anyone else’s opinion.’
      Peace

      • Dear fellow Vincentians, yes I agree that this action might temporarily affect some of the most vulnerable people; but it is unfortunate and OVERDO. We can all agree, that we have limited funds available to assist people and have at times, limited to how much we can assist them. Our government is no different then us, except on a much larger scale. They are legally and morally obligated to be GOOD stewards with the monies allotted to them from WE the people. Our government funding has gotten out of hand. We cannot just keep printing and spending money like there is no consequence or tomorrow.
        There has to be an accounting and where this assistance is being used. We have to re-evaluate all programs and countries that we are sending assistance to. They might have to cut back on some or add to others. It is sad that some countries abuse the assistance and that it does not go to the poor and marginalized that it was sent to help. It is also sad that some of the countries even hate America, the great Satan; and some of the monies are used for programs contrary to our sacred beliefs of Life, Liberty, and Freedom.
        We cannot take care of the whole world by ourselves. Other countries are helping, but we seem to have the largest chunk. We have to get our spending under control. I pray that this process proceeds with the care and understanding in solving these issues with the utmost speed possible. May God bless and guide these people in their most difficult of decisions and may Mother Mary watch over them!
        I am also deeply concerned with the SSVDP National, as reported in the SSVDP E gazette, in regards a need to open a second SSVDP National Office in Washington D.C. Our SSVDP National Office has been in St. Louis forever, as it is situated in the middle of our country. In this modern age of electronics and communication, where you can talk and see multiple people or groups at the same time all over the world; why do we need the expense of another National Office? Is it because you want to be closer to the MONEY and POWER in Washington D.C.? The Lord also taught the virtue of being small and avoiding the temptation of wanting to be big. I am proud of being a SSVDP member for some 40 years and of us being the organization that worked quietly in assisting when needed, without needing the fame and accolades like some organizations do. Let us keep doing the good work as Our Lord instructed and the great example of St. Vincent de Paul and Blessed Frederick Ozanam.
        Respectfully and prayerfully submitted, Charles Kaczorek

        Respectfully, Chuck Kaczorek

      • I think Christ would use the word atrocity to apply to dehumanizing people, demonizing our neighbors and putting profit ahead of love and service. Human beings will starve while “corruption” is “studied.”

      • Well said, John. I truly commend your leadership and your voice on this matter. Having worked as a lobbyist in DC, I can tell you this: unless you’re in the room, you don’t know the full story. As a large and long-established organization, we absolutely deserve a seat at the table in these discussions. Our commitment to serving those in need is critical, and it’s clear that people are suffering. What I hear from you is that discernment is key when making decisions that affect humanity, especially decision that impact the most vulnerable. Hasty decisions are being made, and their ripple effects will be felt for some time. My hope and prayer are that these decisions are being made by people who truly understand what it’s like to grow up without food, shelter, or basic necessities. If those in power don’t know this experience, it’s our responsibility to help them understand how their decisions are impacting those we serve.

  • I understand your heartbreak but I pray this is temporary and the government weeds out the programs that never should have been funded in the first place. That being said, it is our responsibility, the church to care and help, not the governments. We Christians need to step up. For now, God is in control and we need to pray and step up and donate. It is a good time for the program to evaluate where it may need budget adjustments and also cut whatever may be unnecessary spending. We are accountable.

  • First off, you are are wrong regarding a freeze. It is a pause in order to review and sort out waste and corruption. Secondly, I am bewildered and astonished you informing me Catholc Charities receives $1.5 Billion from the federal government. I always thought and told interested people that Catholics are extremely generous. Guess that’s not so much the case. What I hear you telling me is that we as Catholics and our charity is beholden to and obligated to playing nice with government and not separation of church and state. I’m all for investigation to find waste of our taxpayers dollar!

  • I can only speak of my experience.
    I have worked in numerous countries torn apart by war and starvation. CRS and other organizations funded by USAID saved lives and gave hope. Children are now dying. This truly is a matter of life and death. My heart aches. Yes, evaluate the programs and budgets but not at the cost of killing people.

  • Oh My! How disappointing it is that SVDP has jumped into the ring. We are in very decisive times. Things have been going very wrong for a long time. Yes drastic measures have happened. Promises for waste and fraud to be eliminated along with efficiency added has been the call of every elected administration since I have been alive. It has never happened. NOW we see the truth. Most of the recipients had 67 % administrative costs. I am so proud of our SVDP organization for being the complete opposite. All Programs under USAID know that they have a path to notify DOGE and make their case on how their program is providing life saving initiatives. Folks this is the pain before the cure. CRS may need to open their books and have transparency for all to see to get rid of rumors. I don’t know. But I love my Vincentian Family and I realize how we do not all agree on Politics and it has been brought full force into our world dividing us in opinions that take away from our core mission and values. We have a mission and I do not believe this is part of it!

  • To those who are reacting to the reality expressed by Mr Berry is political, could it be you are a bit insecure about the repercussions of your political alignment?

    Perhaps, this is a good thing to be cut off from the government in the long run. Perhaps, it is a good thing to be accused of being money-grubbing by a convert who is also the Vice President of the USA. Perhaps, it can be a rallying cry.

    I am on both the SVdP Council Board and the Catholic Charities Board in my Diocese. While SVdP stands on its own with regard to funding its efforts in my Diocese, its resources are inadequate for the needs of our community. Catholic Charities has more funding and serves more people, but it relies heavily on government funds to do so – 90% of its funding comes from government grants. It’s almost as if CC is a distribution arm of the government.

    This would be fine but for one thing, one very important thing: because the money is coming from the government, CC also has to restrict the use of those funds not on Christian sensitibilites, but the whims of whatever administration is in place. or whatever labyrinth of rules Congress has imposed. How do I know this? I also run two Ministries, one that helps hotel-bound families move out of hotels and one that readies men about to be released from incarceration to prepare for life outside. Due to the needs of people in these communities, I have tried to test CC with requests for people in dire need, Over three years, a dozen such requests have all been denied by CC because of those government restrictions.

    But, I don’t blame CC. They have got to get their funding from somewhere. The parishes in our diocese do not step up to make up the difference. So, maybe this very cruel, poorly thought-out Executive Order will wake up the Catholic Community, and all communities for that matter, such that we collectively realize we cannot rely on the Government to do God’s work! If we want a smaller government, each individual Catholic has to meet Christ’s commandment to love ALL our neighbors, to give to those in need until it hurts, and to work with those who are in need as Christ tells us in Matthew 25.

    Oh, and this definitely is about politics. Catholics and Christians became a single-issue constituency – it has been all about abortion. That is understandable, but it was also likely that in doing so, we would get the thing we want, but suffer much in the aftermath. We have a culture of life, but we have forsaken the lives of hundreds of millions by aligning ourselves with a Party that would use our passion to get elected, give us what we asked for on that one issue, and then have a converted Vice President accuse us of money-grubbing for doing the work the government off-loaded to us.

    We asked for this when we came to rely so heavily on the government, and we aligned ourselves so closely with inherently craven politicians (regardless of party). Let’s use this moment to begin to live more fully in Christ by being infinitely more generous with what God gave us.

  • I spent many years working on and eventually directing corporate efficiency projects. We never started by pausing or cutting entire departments, not because we wanted to be nice, but because cutting without understanding almost always cost the company MORE in the long run. You accidentally cut stuff that the business actually needs to operate, and the consequences don’t get noticed for awhile, by which time they can be quite expensive. First step is to investigate and map out how stuff works and how it produces value (or doesn’t). Then you can see where cuts can safely be made, or rework the process so it’s more efficient. Look first, act second – it’s less expensive.

Skip to content